Mamma Agata's Recipe for Lemon Cake
Recently on my blog, I featured a post guest written by Aaron Stewart, VP of Product Design for MSLO, about his experience at Mamma Agata's Hidden Treasure Cooking School on the Amalfi Coast. Because of the overwhelming positive response to this post, Mamma Agata graciously agreed to share the recipe and photographs of her famous Lemon Cake from her cookbook, Simple and Genuine. Aaron says "I enjoyed hearing all of your stories and dreams of visiting Amalfi. I just made this recipe this weekend for my sister in law, Beba and her husband, Dan. He had three slices, it was so good! Hope you all enjoy it as much as I do! For the rest of the recipes from the class you can buy her award winning cook book that is super easy to follow and has lots of helpful hints. Happy cooking!"
If you would like to purchase the cookbook, please go to Mamma Agata's website.
Recipe is below or download for easy printing here
2 Preparing the ingredients— the French refer to this step as "mise en place," literally "putting in place."
3 Generously buttering the fluted cake pan allows for easy removal later. Softened butter works best. Using your fingers or a pastry brush will help you get into every nook and cranny.
Dolce al limone di Mamma Agata
(Mamma Agata’s Lemon Cake)
300 gr or 1 1/4 cups sugar
250 gr or 2 sticks butter (1/2 lb), PLUS an additional 1.5 Tablespoons butter, to grease the pan
4 eggs
Grated zest of 2 large lemons (4 lemons, if small)
A pinch Sea salt
300 gr or 2 cups “00” Flour
16 gr or 2 tablespoons of Pan degli Angeli Italian baking powder
125 ml or 1/2 cup whole milk
50 gr or 1/4 cup hazelnuts (finely chopped and toasted)
Lemonade Mixture:
300 ml or 1 1/4 cups water
Juice of 3 lemons
8 Tablespoons sugar
1 ) Pre-heat the oven to 175 degrees Celsius or 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Whip the butter in a mixing bowl on high speed for at least two minutes.
2 ) Add the sugar and continue to whip until a soft cream forms. Mix the baking powder into the flour and set aside.
3 ) Add the following ingredients to the mixing bowl, one at a time, and blend after each:
Eggs, one at a time,
salt, grated lemon zest
.
4 ) Alternate adding and blending the following ingredients into the mixing bowl:
Flour and baking powder mixture and milk. In other words, add one quarter of the flour and blend; then, add one quarter of the milk and blend. Repeat this process until all of the flour and milk are blended into the batter.
5 ) Mix the ingredients on medium speed for about five minutes until the texture of the batter has a light and airy consistency (similar to a mousse). NOTE: Do not beat the batter for longer than five minutes after adding the baking powder.
6 ) Coat the surface of the fluted pan with butter before dusting it with flour. Shake off any excess flour before adding your cake batter to the pan. NOTE: This step creates a non-stick surface so that the cake will easily release from the pan and retain its shape.
7 ) Pour the batter into your greased and floured pan.
8 ) Bake the cake in the pre-heated oven for forty minutes.
9 ) While the cake is baking in the oven, prepare the lemonade mixture as follows.
10 ) Squeeze the lemons into a pitcher (or other container from which you can easily pour the lemonade mixture later). Add the sugar to the lemon juice.
Mix until the sugar is fully dissolved in the lemon juice. Add the water.
11 ) Once the lemon cake is finished baking, let it sit for two hours outside the oven to bring it to room temperature.
12 ) Before we start this process, we want to ensure that the cake does NOT stick to the pan. In getting it to room temperature, the butter has solidified and that means there is a risk that the cake will stick to the pan. Here is the process just to ensure it does NOT stick to the pan before we proceed.
13 ) Place a plate on top of the pan. Tip the pan over and carefully shake the cake out of the pan. Immediately, place the cake pan back onto the cake. Carefully turn the pan back over. Remove the plate to expose the cake. This will seem like we have done nothing, but what we have done is to ensure that the cake will not stick later when we are ready to plate it.
14 ) NOTE: If the cake does seem like it wants to stick, you will need to place the cake back in the oven for a few minutes, just to warm the butter, and it will release from the pan easily.
15 ) Now it is time to add the lemonade mixture to the cake – that is what makes it so moist.
16 ) Over thirty minutes: Slowly pour a little bit of the lemonade mixture all over the cake in the pan every ten minutes (i.e. three times in total). This will allow the cake to absorb the lemonade mixture very slowly. You should NOT have used all of the lemonade mixture at this point.
17 ) After thirty minutes, tip the lemon cake onto a serving plate and add the remaining lemonade to the top of the cake, distributing it evenly all over the cake. NOTE: If you feel that the cake is still too dry, you may make a little more of the lemonade.
18 ) Garnish the cake with finely chopped hazelnuts and enjoy!








That looks delicious! Too bad I'm not a cook.
Gloria G!!
Posted by: Gloria | July 26th, 2012 at 12:34 am
Thank you so much Mamma Agata for sharing your wonderful recipe for Lemon Cake. Aaron, you're inspiring me with your testimony to try it! Mamma Agata, your cookbook "Simple and Genuine" looks llike a must have for any kitchen.
Posted by: Cindy F | July 26th, 2012 at 7:10 am
Martha,
That cake looks soooo good! Thanks for sharing this recipe.
Posted by: KLBrown | July 26th, 2012 at 9:26 am
Sounds delish. Where does one get the flour? and paking powder?
Posted by: barbara bade | July 26th, 2012 at 9:34 am
Hi Martha, Aaron Stewart and Mamma Agata certainly are two wonderful, intelligent people who provided us with a new, delicious looking lemon cake! Lemon anything is my favorite and I will make one of those cake whenever I can! Mamma Agata's cookbook, her photos, and her websites are terrific! You and your employees find the best people to share with us and I absolutely enjoy reading the blogs that are presented! Missed seeing you on The Today Show yesterday! Did enjoy your tweets about other places you attended! Sure hope you have a great today! Jan
Posted by: Jan Erickson | July 26th, 2012 at 10:44 am
Hi Martha,
How nice of Mamma Agata to share this recipe! I don't do a lot of baking but this cake looks too good to pass up. I just might give it a whirl especially after reading step #16 - my mouth is watering. I went back and read more of the comments on Aaron's post - I didn't realize there were so many more of them. That really was a great blog though so thanks for having him as a guest. Trish
Posted by: Trish | July 26th, 2012 at 10:55 am
Hi Martha,
How nice should be having Mamma Agata's Cookbook, but living in Brazil I don't know how to do this.
I'd appreciate a hint to do so.
Thanks for sharing with us this delicious recipe.
Malú
Posted by: Maria Lúcia | July 26th, 2012 at 12:40 pm
COULD ANYONE TELL ME WHERE TO PURCHASE MAMA AGATA'S COOKBOOK ON LONG ISLAND?
Posted by: S WILDER | July 26th, 2012 at 3:42 pm
@Barbara B... I have purchased "00" flour from Amazon in the past. I would imagine you can get the baking powder there, too.
Posted by: Lisa | July 26th, 2012 at 8:36 pm
I just ordered Mamma Agata's Cookbook - I also printed out this recipe. Thank you so much Martha! You are wonderful. Soraya.
Posted by: Soraya Jane Kanakis | July 26th, 2012 at 9:23 pm
Hello I was also wondering where I can purchase a Mama Agata cookbook in Connecticut. Thanks
Posted by: Mike Burdo | July 26th, 2012 at 9:55 pm
hi martha i'm julia nita achim.i'm your big fan here in malaysia.i'm watching martha stewart show n i wrote about up to 5 books of all your recipes u know n i want to buy your cookies recipes book but i don't know where to buy lah martha...
Posted by: julia nita achim | July 26th, 2012 at 10:34 pm
Thanks so much for the recipe! I will definitely try to make this soon.
I've been to the Amalfi coast but if I get to go back there, I will sign up for a cooking class. The lemons there are just wonderful. What lovely pictures! I love the photo of the coast with the book and lemons. Also, do you have info on where to get a fluted cake pan exactly like Mamma Agata used?
Posted by: laline | July 26th, 2012 at 11:33 pm
That's a wonderful tip on getting the cake out of the pan. I've had bundt cakes stick to the pan. And now I have the solution to getting them out of the pan without breaking the cake. Thank you ! Also, I love the way Mama serves the cake --- with a whole lemon & leaf in the center s decoration. Yes !
Posted by: Penny | July 27th, 2012 at 12:46 pm
Delicious and easy. Thank you.
Posted by: Kim | August 7th, 2012 at 6:44 am
Lady Martha,
Sono Italiano,quindi mi sembra del tutto naturale commentare nella mia lingua.
Capisco la lingua angloamericana,ma mi trovo a disagio se devo scrivere o parlare.
Io abito a Salerno.Mi ha fatto molto piacere rilevare che si manifesti interesse per
le nostre "terre"così ricche di tradizioni e di bellezze naturali.Per la verità,sono
nato in provincia di Avellino,nota anche per essere luogo di produzione di "castagne".
Tenuto conto della particolare "versatilità" culinaria delle iniziative di questo "blog" e di tutte le altre che lo "complementano",inviterei a tenerne conto,
Desidero manifestare tutta la mia sincera ammirazione nei Suoi (o Tuoi confronti-
si scelga il termine ritenuto piu' adatto).Del resto,forse,gia' noto per tutti i posts
elaborati in diverse sedi ("Google+" e "Forbes"),
E la mia ammirazione non riguarda solo l'attività manageriale e filantropica,ma
si estende anche alle particolari e specifiche qualità di "fascino femminile".
Sono un uomo,e come tutti gli uomini ,particolarmente sensibile in tal senso.
Un virtuale inchino e baciamano,Walter Di Meo.
Posted by: Walter Di Meo | December 7th, 2012 at 4:35 pm